Dining at The Shay: Zaytinya, Butterfly and the Lobby Bar

The Shay’s main on-site dining options are Zaytinya (Mediterranean) on the ground floor, Butterfly (Mexican) on the rooftop around the pool deck, and the Lobby Bar in the hotel lobby. All three serve guests during published hours; 24-hour in-room dining from Zaytinya & Butterfly is also available.
In this guide
Overview: Where to eat at The Shay
The Shay Hotel offers three primary food-and-drink outlets: Zaytinya (Mediterranean), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican concept), and the Lobby Bar. In addition, 24-hour In-Room Dining is available from Zaytinya & Butterfly.
These outlets are operated as restaurant concepts within the hotel; guests can also use the rooftop pool deck area near Butterfly for dining and poolside service.
- Zaytinya — Mediterranean mezze and wood-fired dishes (dinner service).
- Butterfly — rooftop Mexican menu for breakfast, all-day dining, and happy hour.
- Lobby Bar — cocktails, coffee and a game room with a pool table.
| Dining Outlet | Cuisine / Focus | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Zaytinya | Turkish, Greek, Lebanese mezze; wood-fired fish & kebabs | Dinner service; José Andrés Group concept |
| Butterfly | Mexican — tacos, ceviches, agave cocktails | Rooftop, breakfast through dinner, happy hour on weekdays |
| Lobby Bar | Cocktails & coffee | Lobby game room area with pool table; evening hours |

Zaytinya — what to expect
Zaytinya is a José Andrés Group Mediterranean restaurant at The Shay serving mezze (hommus, tzatziki, baba ghannouge), family-style kebabs, whole grilled fish from a wood-fired hearth, and slow-smoked lamb shoulder, with a curated wine list. The hotel lists Zaytinya as its Mediterranean dining partner.
Zaytinya’s published dinner hours on the hotel site are: Monday–Thursday and Sunday 5:00 PM–9:00 PM; Friday–Saturday 5:00 PM–10:00 PM. The restaurant’s phone contact is +1 310 356 0200.
- Cuisine: Turkish, Greek, Lebanese mezze and wood-fired dishes.
- Dress code listed as Casual.
- Reservations are possible; check the restaurant directly for availability.
| Service | Hours (as listed) |
|---|---|
| Dinner | Mon–Thu & Sun 5:00 PM–9:00 PM; Fri–Sat 5:00 PM–10:00 PM |

Butterfly on the rooftop — poolside and views
Butterfly is the rooftop Mexican concept that wraps around the hotel’s pool deck. The hotel lists Butterfly as serving breakfast, an all-day menu, and a weekday happy hour.
Because Butterfly sits on the rooftop, it operates alongside the rooftop pool deck and cabanas; expect an open-air setting and poolside service during the pool’s posted hours.
- Hours (hotel listing): Breakfast daily 7:00 AM–11:00 AM; All-day menu 11:00 AM–9:00 PM; Happy Hour Mon–Fri 4:00 PM–6:00 PM.
- Menu highlights per hotel copy: tacos, ceviches, and cocktails made with additive-free agave spirits.
- Butterfly is casual; reservations and event bookings may apply for private rooftop functions.
| Offer | Hours (as listed) |
|---|---|
| Breakfast | 7:00 AM–11:00 AM |
| All-Day Menu | 11:00 AM–9:00 PM |
| Happy Hour | Mon–Fri 4:00 PM–6:00 PM |

Lobby Bar and casual options
The Lobby Bar is a casual bar in the hotel lobby that offers cocktails and espresso-based drinks from a barista station. The space shares the lobby with a game room that includes a billiards/pool table.
Lobby Bar hours listed on the hotel site are Monday–Thursday and Sunday 4:00 PM–10:00 PM, and Friday–Saturday 4:00 PM–11:00 PM.
- Good for pre-evening drinks, coffee, and a relaxed lobby atmosphere.
- The lobby area includes lounge seating and a game room; it’s designed for casual visits rather than full-service dining.
- In-room dining from Zaytinya & Butterfly is available 24 hours if you prefer to eat in your Room or Suite.
| Service | Hours |
|---|---|
| Cocktails & Coffee | Mon–Thu & Sun 4:00 PM–10:00 PM; Fri–Sat 4:00 PM–11:00 PM |
| In-Room Dining | 24 hours (Zaytinya & Butterfly) |
Tips for dining with kids, events and poolside service
The Shay is family-friendly and children are welcome in the restaurants and on the rooftop pool deck. The hotel notes the rooftop pool is a shallow, lounge-style pool with hours from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Butterfly wraps around that space for poolside dining.
The hotel also offers multiple event spaces on property (Ivy Ballroom, Ivy Courtyard, The Terrace, The Peek, etc.), and the rooftop pool deck functions as an event space for private bookings when reserved.
- Children: The property is family-friendly; follow normal pool rules and the hotel’s guidance for minors in public spaces.
- Private events: rooftop and ballroom spaces are bookable for weddings and receptions—contact the hotel for event menus and availability.
- Pool cabanas can be reserved and offer food and cocktail service when available.
| Feature | What to know |
|---|---|
| Rooftop Pool | Open 8:00 AM–8:00 PM; shallow lounge-style (3 ft described in listings) |
| Cabanas | Reservable; poolside food and cocktail service available |
| Event Dining | Rooftop and ballroom spaces can be booked for private events |
Practical matters: reservations, dress code and in-room dining
Dress codes for the hotel restaurants are listed as Casual. Zaytinya and Butterfly both show Casual dress on the hotel site; some third-party listings use terms like Smart Casual for Zaytinya—when in doubt, lean toward neat casual attire for dinner.
Reservations: Zaytinya accepts reservations; Butterfly may allow walk-ins depending on rooftop availability. For guaranteed seating (especially dinner or weekend brunch), call the restaurant directly or check their booking channels.
- Zaytinya phone: +1 310 356 0200 (hotel listing).
- If you prefer to eat in your room, In-Room Dining from Zaytinya & Butterfly runs 24 hours.
- If you have food allergies or dietary needs, contact the restaurant ahead of time for specifics.
| Need | What to do |
|---|---|
| Reservations for dinner | Call Zaytinya or check online reservations |
| Rooftop seating | Arrive early for seating or check availability; private bookings possible |
| Late-night food | Use 24-hour In-Room Dining |


