
The Shay Hotel
Best for a Culver City base with easy Metro access, a casual rooftop scene, and José Andrés Group dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Shay Hotel is a 4-star, 148-room boutique Destination by Hyatt in Culver City with a rooftop pool, José Andrés Group restaurants, and direct access to the Culver City Metro E Line — read this if you want a convenient, transit-connected Los Angeles base. Fairmont Miramar Hotel is a long-running 5-star Santa Monica luxury hotel steps from the beach with a full-service spa and larger meeting facilities — read this if you prefer beachfront location and traditional luxury amenities.
Updated · about 8 miles (≈13 km) apart

Best for a Culver City base with easy Metro access, a casual rooftop scene, and José Andrés Group dining.

Best for travelers who want to stay within walking distance of Santa Monica Beach and Pier and prefer a larger luxury hotel with a spa.
When The Shay Hotel wins: choose The Shay if you want a smaller, newer boutique hotel close to the Culver City Arts District and the Culver City Metro E Line, enjoy a rooftop pool deck and José Andrés–led restaurants, and prefer a modern, neighborhood-forward stay.
When Fairmont Miramar Hotel wins: choose Fairmont Miramar if being within a short walk of Santa Monica Beach and the Pier, an on-site full-service spa, and larger meeting or event facilities matter most to you.
Bottom line: pick The Shay for Culver City convenience, rooftop vibes, and compact boutique service; pick Fairmont Miramar when beach proximity and traditional luxury hotel services (spa, larger food & beverage and event footprint) are the priority.
| Category | The Shay Hotel | Fairmont Miramar Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modern, boutique, neighborhood-focused | Established luxury hotel with traditional service |
| Location | Adjacent to Ivy Station and Culver City Metro E Line; walkable to local studios and Arts District | Centrally located in Santa Monica within a 15-minute walk of Santa Monica Beach and Pier |
| Size | 148 rooms (19 suites) | 297 guestrooms |
| Who can stay / age policy | All ages welcome; guest checking in must be 21+ | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | One rooftop shallow lounge-style pool (open daily 8:00 AM–8:00 PM) with cabanas and poolside service | Outdoor pool plus hot tub and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican), Lobby Bar; in-room dining 24 hours | Three restaurants, one coffee shop/cafe, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | No in-house spa — partner services available at Milk + Honey Spa nearby; 24-hour fitness center on-site | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, and facials; 24-hour fitness center listed |
| Known for | Transit access, boutique rooftop pool & José Andrés dining | Beach proximity, historic Santa Monica luxury name and large event space |
| Event & meeting space | About 8,000 sq ft of flexible indoor/outdoor event space, several wedding venues including a 3,450 sq ft ballroom | About 25,005 sq ft of conference/banquet space and 7 meeting rooms |
| Parking & transport perks | Covered valet (fee), complimentary EV charging when valet-parked, destination fee includes Metro passes and limited rideshare perks | Secured parking and valet available (surcharge listed); LAX is the preferred airport |
The Shay sits at Ivy Station beside the Culver City Metro E Line stop, making it a well-connected base for exploring LA by public transit and car.
Choose The Shay for transit convenience and quick access to Culver City neighborhoods and studios.
Fairmont Miramar puts you in Santa Monica within walking distance of the beach, Pier, Third Street Promenade and local shopping.
Choose Fairmont Miramar to be centrally located within Santa Monica and within walking distance of the shoreline.
The Shay offers 148 modern rooms across six floors, including 19 suites and several room configurations with balconies and bathtubs.
The Shay works well for travelers who want modern rooms and a compact boutique inventory.
Fairmont Miramar lists a broad mix of room types and suites, from Fairmont Palisades rooms to Signature Bungalows and ocean-view suites.
Fairmont Miramar suits travelers who want more room-type variety and classic luxury room amenities, including ocean-view options.
The Shay features José Andrés Group concepts — Zaytinya (Mediterranean) and Butterfly (rooftop Mexican) — plus the Lobby Bar and 24-hour in-room dining.
The Shay is a good choice for food-focused travelers who want signature restaurant concepts and rooftop dining.
Fairmont Miramar offers multiple on-site dining options (3 restaurants) and a coffee shop/cafe, with room service available during limited hours.
Choose Fairmont Miramar if you want the convenience of multiple on-site restaurants with traditional hotel service.
The Shay's rooftop pool deck is the property's standout public space, described as a shallow lounge-style pool with cabanas and events.
If a social rooftop pool and poolside dining are your priorities, The Shay delivers a focused, neighborhood-oriented experience.
Fairmont Miramar places you within walking distance of the ocean and operates an outdoor pool with adjacent hot tub and poolside bar.
Fairmont Miramar is the better choice when your priority is walking to the beach and having a traditional hotel pool and spa experience nearby.
The Shay emphasizes a rooftop nightlife and event scene and offers partner spa services nearby rather than an on-site full spa.
The Shay is for guests who want a lively rooftop social program and nearby spa partners rather than an on-site full-service spa.
Fairmont Miramar offers an on-site full-service spa and quieter, classic hotel evening options in Santa Monica.
Choose Fairmont Miramar if on-site spa services and a more traditional hotel wellness offering are important.

The Shay — adjacent to Culver City Metro E Line with included Metro passes via the destination fee.

Fairmont Miramar Hotel — an easy walk to Santa Monica Beach and Pier for beach days without driving.

Fairmont Miramar Hotel — full-service spa on property offering massages, facials and body treatments.

The Shay — José Andrés Group-led restaurants and a wraparound rooftop dining concept alongside the pool.
Fairmont Miramar Hotel is in Santa Monica within walking distance of Santa Monica Beach; The Shay is in Culver City about an 8-mile drive from the beach.
No — The Shay partners with Milk + Honey Spa at the adjacent Ivy Station for massages and treatments; Fairmont Miramar has a full-service spa on site.
Fairmont Miramar has a larger conference and banquet footprint (about 25,005 sq ft) and more meeting rooms; The Shay offers roughly 8,000 sq ft of flexible indoor/outdoor event space and several wedding venues.
Yes — both hotels welcome guests of all ages. Note The Shay requires the guest checking in to be at least 21; Fairmont Miramar is not adults-only.
Explore how The Shay Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·