
The Shay Hotel
Best for transit-connected Westside stays, casual dining by José Andrés, and a social rooftop pool scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Shay Hotel is a 4-star, 148-room boutique hotel in Culver City with a rooftop pool deck, José Andrés Group dining, and direct access to the Metro E Line—good for transit-minded travelers, families, and studio visitors. Hotel Bel-Air, Dorchester Collection is a secluded five-star Bel-Air luxury hideaway with extensive spa services and multiple pools—best for travelers seeking classic Los Angeles luxury and privacy.
Updated

Best for transit-connected Westside stays, casual dining by José Andrés, and a social rooftop pool scene.

Best for a quiet, high-end Bel-Air retreat with a comprehensive spa and classic luxury service.
When The Shay Hotel wins: choose The Shay if you want easy public-transit access (adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line), a lively rooftop pool and bar program, contemporary rooms, and on-site José Andrés Group restaurants at generally more approachable service-formality for families and younger groups.
When Hotel Bel-Air wins: pick Hotel Bel-Air - Dorchester Collection if you prioritize secluded grounds, a formal five-star service level, an on-site spa and multiple pool experiences, and a quieter, luxury-focused atmosphere favored by guests seeking privacy.
Bottom line: The Shay is a modern, transit-friendly Westside option with rooftop social spaces and José Andrés dining; Hotel Bel-Air is a traditional five-star Bel-Air hideaway centered on privacy, full-service spa offerings, and classic luxury. Pick based on whether you want a connected, social base (Shay) or a secluded luxury retreat (Bel-Air).
| Category | The Shay Hotel | Hotel Bel-Air Dorchester Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, social, rooftop-focused | Secluded, formal five-star luxury |
| Location | Culver City — adjacent to Ivy Station and the Metro E Line | Bel-Air — quiet residential setting (701 Stone Canyon Road) |
| Size (rooms) | 148 rooms (19 suites) | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; guest checking in must be 21+ | All ages welcome; check-in minimum age not published |
| Pools | Single rooftop outdoor shallow pool (about 3 ft), cabanas and pool bar | Indoor and outdoor pools listed; full pool facilities available |
| Restaurants & bars | Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican), Lobby Bar, poolside bar | On-site restaurant(s), bar, coffee shop and room service (formal dining options) |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; partner Milk + Honey Spa nearby at Ivy Station; 24-hour fitness center on-site | On-site full-service spa with hammam/steamroom and various treatments |
| Known for | Transit access, rooftop pool events, José Andrés dining | Seclusion, celebrity and luxury reputation, top-tier service |
| Event & meeting space | About 8,000 sq ft of indoor/outdoor event space including a 3,450 sq ft Ivy Ballroom and rooftop event deck | Meeting/banquet facilities available (details vary by event) |
The Shay sits at Ivy Station in Culver City, directly adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line stop.
Choose The Shay if you want a transit-connected Westside base with easy neighborhood walking options.
Hotel Bel-Air is located on Stone Canyon Road in the Bel-Air neighborhood, set on secluded grounds.
Choose Hotel Bel-Air for a private Bel-Air address and a quieter setting away from transit hubs.
The Shay has 148 rooms and 19 suites with modern design across six floors.
The Shay emphasizes modern, recently built rooms and a range of suites suitable for families and groups.
Hotel Bel-Air offers a range of deluxe rooms and suites described in supplier lists by type.
Hotel Bel-Air focuses on classic luxury room types and private-suite experiences, including rooms with patios and fireplaces.
The Shay houses José Andrés Group concepts and casual bars, anchored by rooftop dining.
Expect lively, chef-driven dining and a rooftop scene at The Shay, with options spanning breakfast to late-night room service.
Hotel Bel-Air's supplier listing shows on-site restaurants, bars, coffee shop and room service.
Hotel Bel-Air offers formal, classic luxury dining on property; expect quieter, service-led meal experiences.
The Shay's signature amenity is its rooftop outdoor pool deck focused on social programming.
The Shay's rooftop pool is a social, event-friendly shallow pool best for lounging and daytime programming.
Hotel Bel-Air lists multiple pool facilities, both indoor and outdoor.
Hotel Bel-Air provides a broader pool setup with indoor and outdoor options for a more varied swim and relaxation experience.
The Shay supports wellness with a 24-hour fitness center and partner spas nearby.
The Shay mixes a strong fitness offering with nearby spa partnerships and casual nightlife programming on property.
Hotel Bel-Air offers comprehensive on-site spa and wellness features.
Hotel Bel-Air is oriented toward in-house wellness and quiet evenings, centered on a full-service spa and leisurely pace.

The Shay — located directly adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line station with complimentary metro passes included in the destination-fee package.

Hotel Bel-Air — on-site spa, multiple pool types, and a long-standing reputation for private, luxury service.

The Shay — rooftop Butterfly restaurant wraps the pool deck and the hotel runs pop-up events and cabana programming.

Hotel Bel-Air — suited to travelers seeking low-profile privacy and traditional five-star service.
Pick The Shay — it sits adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line, making rail access to LA attractions straightforward.
Hotel Bel-Air has an on-site full-service spa; The Shay partners with nearby Milk + Honey Spa rather than operating its own spa.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages. Note The Shay requires the guest checking in to be at least 21 years old.
The Shay — it has a shallow rooftop pool, cabanas, poolside bar, and regular pop-up events aimed at a social daytime crowd.
Explore how The Shay Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·