
The Shay Hotel
Best for city-focused travelers who want a social rooftop pool, direct Metro access, and José Andrés Group restaurants on site.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Shay Hotel is a 148-room, 4-star boutique Destination by Hyatt in Culver City with a rooftop pool deck, José Andrés Group dining, and direct access to the Culver City Metro E Line. Shutters on the Beach is a landmark 5-star beachfront luxury hotel in Santa Monica; this guide helps travelers choose between an urban, transit-linked rooftop experience and a classic oceanfront resort stay.
Updated · about 8 miles (≈13 km) apart

Best for city-focused travelers who want a social rooftop pool, direct Metro access, and José Andrés Group restaurants on site.

Best for travelers who want direct beach access, traditional oceanfront luxury, and an on-site full-service spa.
When The Shay Hotel wins: Choose The Shay if you prefer a neighborhood base on the Westside with easy public-transit links, a lively rooftop pool and restaurants (Zaytinya and Butterfly), and modern, compact boutique rooms—good for city sightseeing and Culver City nightlife.
When Shutters on the Beach wins: Pick Shutters when your priority is being steps from Santa Monica Beach and the Santa Monica Pier, with a classic beach-hotel atmosphere, a full-service spa, and direct sand-and-ocean access for daytime beach plans.
Bottom line: The Shay is an urban, transit-friendly boutique pick with a social rooftop and José Andrés Group cuisine; Shutters is a traditional luxury beachfront resort. Your choice depends on whether you want city access and a rooftop vibe (Shay) or onsite beach time and full spa services (Shutters).
| Category | The Shay Hotel | Shutters on the Beach |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary boutique with a social rooftop and neighborhood focus | Classic beachfront luxury resort-style hotel |
| Location | Culver City, adjacent to Ivy Station and the Metro E Line | Santa Monica, directly on Santa Monica Beach and near the Pier |
| Size (rooms) | 148 rooms, 19 suites | 198 guestrooms (listing) |
| Ages / policy | Family-friendly; guest checking in must be 21+ | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools / beach | One rooftop outdoor shallow pool (open 8:00 AM–8:00 PM) with cabanas and pool bar | Outdoor pool plus direct beach access and beach sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican), Lobby Bar, poolside service | Coast and additional on-site dining options, 2 restaurants and bars (24-hour room service available) |
| Spa & wellness | No in-house spa; partner Milk + Honey Spa at adjacent Ivy Station (bookable perks) | Full-service on-site spa offering massages, body treatments, facials |
| Transit & access | Directly adjacent to Metro E Line station; included Metro single-ride passes via the destination fee | Best reached by car or rideshare; nearest major airport LAX preferred |
| Event space | About 8,000 sq ft of flexible indoor/outdoor event space including Ivy Ballroom and rooftop event areas | Multiple meeting rooms and banquet/wedding services (7 meeting rooms listed) |
| Parking & fees | Valet parking for a fee; $30 nightly destination fee (covers Metro passes, rideshare drop-offs, spa perks) | Valet parking (surcharge) and various optional fees (breakfast, airport shuttle, parking noted) |
The Shay sits at Ivy Station in Culver City with immediate access to the Metro E Line and nearby arts and studio districts.
Choose The Shay for transit-linked access and a Culver City neighborhood base.
Shutters on the Beach is located directly on Santa Monica Beach and steps from the Santa Monica Pier.
Choose Shutters for immediate beach access and walkable Santa Monica attractions.
Rooms at The Shay emphasize modern boutique design across 148 rooms and 19 suites with contemporary amenities.
The Shay suits guests who want modern rooms with urban views and flexible suite options.
Shutters offers traditional beachfront guest rooms and suites, many with partial or full ocean views.
Shutters is the pick when an ocean view or direct beach proximity is a priority.
The Shay features José Andrés Group-led Zaytinya, rooftop Butterfly, and a Lobby Bar tied into the hotel's social spaces.
The Shay is for guests who want notable chef-driven options and rooftop dining tied to the pool scene.
Shutters on the Beach focuses on beachfront dining with Coast as a signature on-site restaurant and 24-hour room service.
Shutters suits travelers who want classic hotel dining steps from the sand.
The Shay's main water feature is a shallow rooftop pool deck designed for lounging and events.
Pick The Shay if you want a curated rooftop-pool social scene and skyline views.
Shutters provides a traditional hotel pool plus immediate access to Santa Monica Beach and beach amenities.
Choose Shutters when beach proximity and ocean access are the main draw.
The Shay relies on nearby wellness partners and an adjacent Milk + Honey Spa for in-person treatments.
The Shay covers fitness and partners for spa services, focusing nightlife on rooftop and neighborhood options.
Shutters features an on-site full-service spa and fitness facilities as part of its beachfront resort offer.
Shutters is better if you want an all-on-property spa and beach-centered wellness.

The Shay — adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line with included single-ride passes via the destination fee.

Shutters on the Beach — steps from Santa Monica Beach and the Pier with beach loungers and umbrellas.

Shutters — a full-service on-site spa offering massages, facials, and body treatments.

The Shay — rooftop pool with cabanas and José Andrés Group dining (Zaytinya) plus Butterfly rooftop concept.
Both welcome families. The Shay is family-friendly with a rooftop pool kids use and family-size rooms; Shutters offers beachfront access and family-friendly beach days.
Shutters on the Beach — it’s directly on Santa Monica Beach, steps from the sand and the Pier.
Shutters has a full-service on-site spa. The Shay partners with Milk + Honey Spa at the adjacent Ivy Station; there is no in-house Shay spa.
Yes — The Shay is adjacent to the Metro E Line and provides single-ride Metro passes as part of its destination-fee package.
Explore how The Shay Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·