
The Shay Hotel
Best for city-access and nightlife-adjacent stays—easy transit, neighborhood restaurants, studios and Culver City attractions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Shay Hotel is a 4-star, 148-room urban boutique hotel in Culver City with a rooftop pool deck and José Andrés Group dining—good for travelers who want a walkable, transit-connected LA base. Malibu Beach Inn is an upscale 4.5-star beachfront boutique hotel on Carbon Beach for travelers prioritizing an oceanfront escape and private-beach access.
Updated

Best for city-access and nightlife-adjacent stays—easy transit, neighborhood restaurants, studios and Culver City attractions.

Best for a classic Malibu oceanfront stay—rooms with private balconies, beach access, and a full-service spa experience.
When The Shay Hotel wins: choose The Shay for a connected Westside LA experience—direct access to the Metro E Line, rooftop pool and lively on-site dining by José Andrés Group make it a better fit for city-focused travelers and those who want transit convenience.
When Malibu Beach Inn wins: pick Malibu Beach Inn if your priority is beachfront time, private beach service, ocean views from balconies and on-site spa and beach-focused activities.
Bottom line: The Shay and Malibu Beach Inn serve different trip types—pick Culver City for urban access and rooftop social life, pick Malibu for a seaside retreat and beach access.
| Category | The Shay Hotel | Malibu Beach Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Urban, design-forward boutique anchored to Ivy Station and Culver City life | Upscale beachfront boutique focused on oceanfront rooms and private beach time |
| Location | Culver City, adjacent to Metro E Line and Ivy Station (walkable neighborhood) | Malibu (Eastern Malibu), steps from Malibu Lagoon State Beach and Malibu Pier |
| Size | 148 rooms, 19 suites | 47 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; guest checking in must be 21+ | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools / beach | Rooftop outdoor pool deck (shallow lounge-style 3 ft pool, 8:00 AM–8:00 PM) | On private beach with beach sun loungers and umbrellas (hotel listing mentions private beach; on-site pool not published) |
| Restaurants & bars | Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican), Lobby Bar, poolside bar | Carbon Beach Club (Californian cuisine), 24-hour room service, breakfast available for a fee |
| Spa & wellness | No in-house spa; partnered access to Milk + Honey Spa at adjacent Ivy Station; 24-hour fitness center on-site | Full-service spa on property offering facials and spa services |
| Known for | Rooftop pool deck, José Andrés dining, event/wedding spaces and transit access | Oceanfront rooms with private balconies, private beach and beachfront dining |
| Parking & transit | Covered valet parking (fee), complimentary destination-fee perks including Metro passes | Valet parking (surcharge); nearest airports listed (LAX ~26.6–30.8 mi depending on airport) |
| Rooms highlight | 14 room types including multiple suites and rooftop/penthouse options | Room types include King Pier View Room, KING PREMIER OCEANFRONT, 1 Bedroom Ocean Front Suite, Junior Suite and others; private balconies common |
The Shay sits in downtown Culver City at Ivy Station next to the Metro E Line—easy rail access and walkable neighborhood dining and cultural sites.
Choose The Shay if you want transit convenience and proximity to Culver City's restaurants, studios and museums.
Malibu Beach Inn is located on Pacific Coast Highway in Eastern Malibu, steps from Malibu Lagoon State Beach and Malibu Pier.
Choose Malibu Beach Inn if you want direct oceanfront access and the quiet of Malibu beaches.
The Shay has 148 rooms and 19 suites across contemporary, design-forward room types, including rooftop and penthouse suites.
The Shay is best if you want more room-type choices and new-property finishes in a city setting.
Malibu Beach Inn offers about 47 individually decorated guestrooms focused on ocean and pier views with private balconies.
Malibu Beach Inn centers rooms on ocean views and private balconies—ideal for beach-focused stays.
The Shay offers multiple on-site dining concepts including Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), the rooftop Butterfly and a Lobby Bar.
Choose The Shay for a varied on-site dining program and a rooftop dining-and-pool scene.
Malibu Beach Inn’s dining centers on Carbon Beach Club and room service—dining tailored to an oceanfront setting.
Malibu Beach Inn is a better pick if you want beachfront dining and scenic ocean-view meals.
The Shay’s signature outdoor amenity is its rooftop pool deck and lounge—an urban social space with cabanas and events.
Pick The Shay for rooftop pool life and views over Culver City rather than ocean swimming.
Malibu Beach Inn centers on private beach access and beach amenities rather than a prominent hotel pool.
Choose Malibu Beach Inn when beach access and oceanfront lounging are the main priorities.
The Shay supports wellness with a 24-hour fitness center and partnerships for spa services; nightlife is neighborhood- and rooftop-focused.
The Shay works for active travelers who also want casual evening social spots and easy fitness access.
Malibu Beach Inn leans on on-site spa services and peaceful beachfront evenings rather than bars or city nightlife.
Pick Malibu Beach Inn for spa treatments and low-key, beachfront evenings.

The Shay — adjacent to the Metro E Line and in walking distance of Culver City attractions.

Malibu Beach Inn — private beach access and rooms with ocean-facing balconies.

The Shay — rooftop pool deck with cabanas, events and a poolside bar.

Malibu Beach Inn — on-property full-service spa and beachfront relaxation options.
Malibu Beach Inn — it sits on Carbon Beach with private beach access and ocean-view rooms.
The Shay — it’s adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line and within walking distance of the Arts District and local studios.
The Shay does not operate an in-house spa; guests arrange spa services at the nearby Milk + Honey Spa at Ivy Station.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Shay does require the person checking in to be at least 21.
Explore how The Shay Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·