
The Shay Hotel
Best for transit connections, neighborhood access (Arts District/Helms Bakery), and a lively rooftop dining and pool scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Shay Hotel is a 4-star boutique Destination by Hyatt in Culver City with a rooftop pool, José Andrés Group restaurants, and direct access to the Metro E Line — good for transit-minded travelers who want a modern Westside base near studios and downtown Culver City. Santa Monica Proper Hotel is a design-forward 5-star lifestyle hotel in downtown Santa Monica with a full-service spa and closer beach access — aimed at travelers who want a stylish, full-service coastal stay near Santa Monica attractions.
Updated · about 8 miles (≈13 km) apart

Best for transit connections, neighborhood access (Arts District/Helms Bakery), and a lively rooftop dining and pool scene.

Best for travelers who want a luxury, design-oriented hotel close to Santa Monica shopping, pier, and beach-side activities.
When The Shay wins: Choose The Shay if you want easy Metro access, a smaller boutique scale (148 rooms), and rooftop bars/restaurants by the José Andrés Group — ideal for neighborhood walks and studio-area visits.
When Santa Monica Proper wins: Choose Santa Monica Proper if you want a larger five-star hotel (261 rooms), an on-site full-service spa, and a more central Santa Monica location for beach and promenade time.
Bottom line: The Shay is the better Westside, transit-connected, culinary-forward choice in Culver City; Santa Monica Proper is the better option for a higher-touch, design-led Santa Monica stay with more extensive hotel amenities and spa services.
| Category | The Shay Hotel | Santa Monica Proper Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, neighborhood-forward with playful rooftop dining and local programming | Design-forward five-star lifestyle hotel with a focus on luxury public spaces |
| Location | Culver City, adjacent to Ivy Station and the Metro E Line | Downtown Santa Monica, short drive to Santa Monica Beach and Pier |
| Size | 148 rooms, including 19 suites | 261 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; guest checking in must be 21+ | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age not published |
| Pools | Rooftop outdoor shallow lounge-style pool (≈3 ft), cabanas, pool bar; open 8:00 AM–8:00 PM | Outdoor pool, wheelchair-accessible, poolside bar; pool access and hours published by hotel |
| Restaurants & bars | Zaytinya (José Andrés Group), Butterfly (rooftop Mexican), Lobby Bar; in-room dining 24 hours | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge and a coffee shop/cafe; daily local-cuisine breakfast available (surcharge) |
| Spa & wellness | No in-house spa; partner day-spa Milk + Honey at adjacent Ivy Station (bookable via hotel) | Full-service on-site spa offering massages and treatments |
| Event & meeting space | About 8,000 sq ft total; Ivy Ballroom (≈3,450 sq ft) plus several outdoor and rooftop event venues | Conference space ≈24,000 sq ft (5 meeting rooms) and banquet facilities |
| Transit / beach access | Direct adjacency to the Culver City Metro E Line; good for transit across LA | Close to Santa Monica attractions; hotel is 1.2 mi (≈2 km) from Santa Monica Beach |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly (up to two dogs/cats, fee applies) | Pet policy: Not published |
The Shay sits beside Ivy Station and the Culver City Metro E Line, placing you within walking distance of the Arts District, Helms Bakery District, and nearby studios.
Best if you want transit connections and a Culver City neighborhood base.
Santa Monica Proper sits in downtown Santa Monica near shopping, Third Street Promenade, and a short drive or shuttle to the beach.
Best if you want a central Santa Monica address with easier beach access.
The Shay is a 148-room boutique hotel with 19 suites, offering modern rooms and several suite tiers.
Choose The Shay for a compact, modern boutique inventory and a selection of suites.
Santa Monica Proper offers 261 air-conditioned rooms across multiple categories, from standard rooms to premier suites.
Choose Santa Monica Proper for more room options and a larger five-star property footprint.
The Shay emphasizes dining by the José Andrés Group across a ground-floor and rooftop program plus a lobby bar.
Choose The Shay if you want on-site, chef-driven dining and rooftop dining integrated with the pool.
Santa Monica Proper has two restaurants, a bar/lounge, and a coffee shop/cafe on property.
Choose Santa Monica Proper if you prefer a full-service hotel with multiple dining outlets in downtown Santa Monica.
The Shay’s signature amenity is its rooftop lounge-style pool deck and cabanas with a poolside bar and event programming.
Choose The Shay for a social rooftop pool experience integrated with dining and events.
Santa Monica Proper offers an outdoor pool and a beach shuttle for reaching Santa Monica’s sand and pier.
Choose Santa Monica Proper if you want hotel pool time plus easier access to Santa Monica beach.
The Shay has a 24-hour wheelchair-accessible fitness center and partners with local spas and wellness studios.
Choose The Shay for strong fitness offerings, nearby spa access, and a lively rooftop nightlife/dining scene.
Santa Monica Proper includes a full-service on-site spa plus fitness and design-led public spaces.
Choose Santa Monica Proper for an on-site spa and a higher-touch wellness experience.

The Shay — adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line and steps from Ivy Station, ideal for exploring LA by transit and visiting nearby studios.

Santa Monica Proper — closer to the beach and with an on-site full-service spa for guests who want coastal access and hotel spa treatments.

The Shay — rooftop pool deck with reservable cabanas and José Andrés Group restaurants (Zaytinya, Butterfly) integrated into the rooftop experience.

Santa Monica Proper — bigger property with more rooms, banquet/conference capacity and a design-focused five-star positioning.
Santa Monica Proper is better — it’s in downtown Santa Monica and about 1.2 mi (≈2 km) from Santa Monica Beach, with a hotel beach shuttle available for a surcharge.
The Shay — it’s adjacent to the Culver City Metro E Line stop and often includes Metro single-ride passes as part of the destination-fee package.
Santa Monica Proper has a full-service on-site spa. The Shay does not operate an in-house spa but partners with Milk + Honey Spa at adjacent Ivy Station.
Both have strong on-site dining: The Shay features José Andrés Group concepts including Zaytinya and Butterfly plus a lobby bar; Santa Monica Proper has two restaurants and a bar/cafe in a full-service hotel setting.
Explore how The Shay Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·